Miss Hall’s School Sex Abuse: Lawsuits & How to Get Help
All-female boarding school Miss Hall’s School is facing allegations that one of its former teachers sexually abused students for decades during his tenure. Since 2024, more and more women are coming forward to report sexual abuse they experienced at the school as minors. While the state is not pursuing a criminal case against this teacher or the school, survivors of abuse at Miss Hall’s School may still be able to file a civil sexual assault lawsuit to hold their perpetrators and the institutions that enabled them accountable.
If you or a loved one experienced sexual abuse, grooming, or harassment as a student at Miss Hall’s School, you have rights and legal options for pursuing justice. Contact Helping Survivors today to learn more and get connected with a trusted sexual abuse law firm.
"*" indicates required fields
Author: Kathryn Kosmides
- Multiple women have come forward with allegations of sexual abuse by Miss Hall’s School teacher Matthew Rutledge, who worked at the school from 1991 to 2024.
- At least five women have filed lawsuits against Rutledge and various school administrative staff for fostering a culture of abuse and silence.
- If you experienced sexual abuse as a student at Miss Hall’s School, you have rights and legal options for pursuing justice.
Overview of Miss Hall’s Sexual Abuse Allegations
Founded in 1898 as a small all-girls boarding school in Pittsfield, Massachusetts, Miss Hall’s School was one of the first of its kind in the state, teaching and housing female students in grades nine through 12. In 2024, the school became the center of multiple investigations into teacher conduct after several lawsuits accused former history teacher Matthew Rutledge of grooming, exploiting, and sexually abusing young students for years. Rutledge resigned after the allegations surfaced in early 2024.
The lawsuits, filed by graduates of the school now in their 30s, accuse Rutledge of using his roles as a coach, teacher, and advisor to gain students’ trust before sexually abusing them on and off campus. Victims say Rutledge provided certain students with gifts and special attention, got them alone under the pretense of academic help, engaged in inappropriate sexual contact with students, and threatened suicide if they were to speak out.
According to the legal complaints, the school’s administration received multiple reports about Rutledge’s behavior between 1994 and 2008 but failed to take any real action to prevent further harm.
Legal Rights & Options for Miss Hall’s School Attendees Impacted by Sexual Abuse
File a Miss Hall’s School Abuse Civil Lawsuit
The Massachusetts civil statute of limitations, which is the deadline victims have for filing a case, is 35 years from the date the sexual abuse occurred or seven years from the time the victim discovered an emotional or psychological injury from the abuse. The statute of limitations for negligent conduct contributing to the sexual abuse of minors is the same.
For criminal cases involving minors under 16, the statute of limitations for child sexual abuse is 27 years from when the abuse was reported to law enforcement or from the victim’s 16th birthday, whichever is earlier. However, corroborating evidence such as DNA can extend this deadline indefinitely. For older victims, the criminal statute of limitations for rape and sexual assault is 15 years.
Report Miss Hall’s School Abuse to State Oversight Agencies
Massachusetts has multiple agencies that oversee sexual abuse, including the Governor’s Council to Address Sexual Assault and Domestic Violence and the Massachusetts Children’s Alliance. The Governor’s Council maintains a list of resources for sexual abuse victims and advises the Governor on how to help people in Massachusetts live a life free of sexual abuse.
The Massachusetts Children’s Alliance helps child abuse victims receive the best possible care and provides interventions, education, and legislative support.
Report Sexual Abuse to Law Enforcement
It’s not uncommon for victims of sexual abuse to report it months or years after it occurred. Those who have been subjected to sexual abuse by teachers and administrative personnel may feel a sense of shame or guilt, delaying or preventing reporting. Though it is an extremely difficult task for any survivor, it is crucial to report the abuse you experienced to the authorities, especially if you aim to take legal action against the perpetrator. In Massachusetts, victims of child sexual abuse have 27 years from the abuse to report it to law enforcement.
Reporting sexual abuse to law enforcement can aid your case regardless of whether you pursue criminal charges or file a civil lawsuit. A prosecutor files criminal charges. They aim to punish the perpetrator with jail time or fines. Conversely, the victim pursues a civil lawsuit against the perpetrator and any institutions that enabled their behavior to recover financial compensation for their suffering and losses.
While an experienced sexual abuse attorney can help with many aspects of your case, they can’t report your abuse to the authorities for you. In Massachusetts, you can contact your local police department or the Child-at-Risk Hotline at 1-800-792-5200 to report child sexual abuse, even if it occurred years ago.
How a Sex Abuse Attorney Can Help
If you were sexually abused at Miss Hall’s School, you have legal rights and options for pursuing justice and compensation. At Helping Survivors, we’re on a mission to help heal, educate, and empower sexual assault and abuse survivors by informing them of their rights and resources and making legal introductions to partner law firms.
Every survivor’s experience is unique, and what you choose to do after experiencing abuse is ultimately your choice. There is no right or wrong answer after experiencing harm. However, if you decide you want to take legal action for the abuse you endured, Helping Survivors can help. We’ll connect you with experienced, compassionate lawyers to file a civil lawsuit against the perpetrator of your abuse and the institutions that allowed it.
Miss Hall’s School Sex Abuse In the News
In early 2024, a former Miss Hall’s School student filed the first lawsuit against the institution over sexual abuse by Matthew Rutledge. The suit also named the former dean of students, Sarah Virden, and several school administrators as complicit in creating a school culture that allowed and even normalized physical intimacy between staff and minor students. Melissa Fares, a 2010 graduate of Miss Hall’s, said the school failed to prevent her sexual abuse by Rutledge and that the culture Virden fostered directly caused this abuse. According to Fares’ suit, students were allowed to be alone with faculty day or night, behind closed doors on and off campus.
Fares’ suit also alleged negligence by former Head of School Jeannie Norris, claiming she knew or should have known about Rutledge’s behavior. Fares is one of five alums who have since made legal accusations against Rutledge and other school staff members, and more than two dozen alums have come forward to speak about the teacher’s past behavior. The Berkshire District Attorney’s Office dropped its investigation into Rutledge because Massachusetts’ age of consent is 16, and the alleged victims were older when the conduct occurred. However, civil lawsuits can still proceed. Meanwhile, Miss Hall’s Board of Trustees claims it is still investigating Rutledge’s actions at the school.
Want To Speak With A Lawyer?
